What Actually Makes Sense (and Saves You Money)
When it comes to screen door replacement vs screen door repair, most homeowners are surprised to learn that replacement can usually be avoided.
As long as you still have your original screen door frame — and that’s the case about 95% of the time — we can repair it. Screen door repair is almost always faster, more cost-effective, and less wasteful than buying a brand-new door.
At Mr. Cranky, our first goal is to fix what you already have and save you money. Only when a repair truly isn’t practical do we recommend replacement.
Screen Door Repair Is Usually the Smarter Option
If your sliding screen door:
-
Wobbles side to side
-
Is hard to open or won’t stay on the track
-
Has torn or sagging screen mesh
-
Has rollers that are seized, flat-spotted, or broken
-
Has corners that have pulled apart
…good news: it can almost always be repaired.
We re-screen window screens and door screens, replace worn rollers, fix frames, and carry parts for most screen doors, including older and discontinued models. That’s why a repair is normally far more cost-effective than replacement.
Important tip:
* Never throw away your old screen door frame. Even if it looks rough or is sitting in a heap in the garage, chances are we can rebuild it and bring it back to life for a fraction of the cost of a new one.
Mr. Cranky Carries Screen Door Parts (Lots of Them)
Unlike big box stores, we don’t rely on “one-size-fits-all” solutions.
We stock a wide range of:
-
Steel and upgraded screen door rollers
-
Corner keys and frame components
-
Bug strips and weather seals
-
Screen mesh options (fiberglass, pet-resistant, etc.)
Because we carry the right parts, most screen door repairs can be completed on the spot, without delays or guesswork.
When Screen Door Replacement Does Make Sense
Sometimes a replacement is the right call — for example, if the original frame is missing, severely bent, or beyond repair.
In those cases, we offer custom screen door replacement, not flimsy off-the-shelf junk.
Our Custom Sliding Screen Doors Include:
-
Heavy-duty extruded aluminum frames (much stronger than roll-formed aluminum)
-
High-quality steel rollers — not cheap nylon rollers
-
Internal reinforced corners for long-term durability
-
Integrated locking mechanism (not a security door, but adds peace of mind)
-
Choice of bug strip to keep insects out
-
9 colour options to match your home
Every replacement screen door is made to measure, ensuring smooth operation and a proper fit.
Why Box Store Screen Doors Are a Bad Idea
“Universal” screen doors sold at DIY and big box stores sound convenient — until you try to use one.
These doors are typically:
-
Flimsy and poorly supported
-
Made with thin aluminum that twists easily
-
Equipped with cheap nylon rollers
-
Poorly sealed, letting bugs inside
-
Rarely a proper fit
Don’t just take our word for it — read the reviews. Most homeowners end up frustrated, returning the door, or calling someone like us to fix it anyway.
Made-to-Measure Screen Doors & New Window Screens
Whether you need:
-
A new sliding screen door
-
New window screens
-
Re-screening of existing frames
-
Or a replacement for a missing screen entirely
Mr. Cranky will measure properly, build it right, and install it so it actually works.
Enjoy fresh air, smooth operation, and a bug-free home — without wasting money on unnecessary replacements.
Frequently Asked Questions – Screen Door Repair & Replacement
Yes. Even if your screen door frame is bent, falling apart, or sitting in the garage, do not throw it away. We can repair and rebuild most frames.
In most cases, screen door repair is far cheaper. If you still have the original frame, we can usually re-screen it, replace rollers, or repair corners for a fraction of the cost of replacement.
Absolutely. We re-screen window screens and door screens, replace damaged mesh, and supply new screens when needed.
Yes. We stock a wide range of screen door rollers, corners, bug strips, and hardware, including parts for discontinued and older models.
Replacement is recommended only when the original frame is missing or beyond repair. In those cases, we offer custom, made-to-measure sliding screen doors — not flimsy box-store doors.